Frost Bowl timeline: 1976-2024
Hamburg leads 24-19-1
| Year | Winner | Score | Winning coach |
| 2024 | Schuylkill Valley | 30-21 | Bruce Harbach |
| 2023 | Schuylkill Valley | 28-13 | Bruce Harbach |
| 2022 | Schuylkill Valley | 41-34 | Bruce Harbach |
| 2021 | Hamburg | 21-13 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2020 | Hamburg | 45-6 | Chuck Kutz |
| 2019 | Hamburg | 42-7 | Chuck Kutz |
| 2018 | Schuylkill Valley | 14-13 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2017 | Schuylkill Valley | 13-7 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2016 | Hamburg | 23-14 | Chuck Kutz |
| 2015 | Hamburg | 49-7 | Damian Buggy |
| 2014 | Schuylkill Valley | 35-21 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2013 | Schuylkill Valley | 34-13 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2012 | Schuylkill Valley | 42-14 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2011 | Schuylkill Valley | 48-33 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2010 | Schuylkill Valley | 20-14 | Jeff Chillot |
| 2009 | Hamburg | 29-21 | Joe Sinkovich |
| 2008 | Hamburg | 38-16 | Joe Sinkovich |
| 2007 | Hamburg | 37-19 | Joe Sinkovich |
| 2006 | Hamburg | 42-6 | Joe Sinkovich |
| 2005 | Schuylkill Valley | 34-20 | Cory Mabry |
| 2004 | Schuylkill Valley | 27-8 | Preston McKnight |
| 2003 | Schuylkill Valley | 35-0 | Preston McKnight |
| 2002 | Schuylkill Valley | 14-7 OT | Preston McKnight |
| 2001 | Schuylkill Valley | 55-6 | Preston McKnight |
| 2000 | Hamburg | 20-19 | Rick Keeley |
| 1999 | Hamburg | 28-6 | Rick Keeley |
| 1998 | Schuylkill Valley | 34-27 | George Newton |
| 1997 | Hamburg | 48-18 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1991 | Hamburg | 38-8 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1990 | Hamburg | 27-6 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1989 | Hamburg | 14-3 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1988 | Hamburg | 27-7 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1987 | Schuylkill Valley | 25-12 | Jay Mosely |
| 1986 | Hamburg | 36-0 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1985 | Hamburg | 56-8 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1984 | Hamburg | 41-12 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1983 | Hamburg | 13-6 | Bill Sakusky |
| 1982 | Schuylkill Valley | 20-14 | Ted Jamula |
| 1981 | Hamburg | 27-8 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1980 | Hamburg | 28-14 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1979 | Tie | 6-6 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1978 | Hamburg | 8-6 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1977 | Hamburg | 21-7 | Joe Leonzi |
| 1976 | Schuylkill Valley | 26-8 | Pete Starr |
The schools met six times between 1970-75 before the trophy was introduced.
